Ok so let's trade (in your words) a "phenomenal player" on a weapons-strapped offense for Colt McCoy, a middling at best QB who's about as bad as Colt 45. Sure, why not?
I think it's a good thought. My only problem is that you are asking for too little. Don't be afraid to go after fair market value. I'm thinking we should talk to Green Bay and offer them Percy the Phenomenal for Aaron Rodgers and their 2015 first rounder.