I think Clemens will be good but he hasnt poved anything yet, many scouts were saying Ryan Leaf was the next best thing, he wasnt, your argument does nothing for the Clemens supporters.
Ryan Leaf was Ryan Leaf. Anybody with any personal exposure to that guy during college and while being drafted would say that he was a complete idiot. The physical skills were never in question, it was the mental side that made him implode. I had some friends that went to WSU during that time and Leaf had a reputation of having a massive temper and often threw tantrums during practice. If anything, I would say that clemen's is the anti-leaf in almost every aspect in terms of mental makeup.