Separate names with a comma.
I actually like Simpson enough to consider him a 1st round pick, it's just that lack of starts, older age with that lack of starts, lack of size,...
I would not give 2nd for Tanner, so the whole premise is not really there. But with vets you can evaluate a lot faster than rookies. Also I even...
Every two years I would understand. At least you evaluated the guy for two years, not just as a rookie, like Minny did, and JJ totally sucks i...
I believe you are talking about me. I agree it is not exact science, yes. At the same time i have provided evidence that getting a QB beyond mid...
I am in complete agreement that we may not be able to trade up next year. Which is why I was pretty mad when we won two meaningless games by...
Look, it's not about 1st overall. I just showed you legitimate data that there were about 100 QBs drafted late second round or below in the last...
The thing is, if we get #1 pick, sure, even if we drafted Simpson, screw him, we draft Manning, that's not that hard. But we probably won't get #...
My point about below mid or so second round does not apply to Simpson. And over time what I observed is the opposite of what you are saying: the...
As you said, Hurts was mid second round, still a high pick. Purdy I guess, but again, is he FQB for a team without Shanahan level coach? Shanahan...
No matter how good their eye for talent is, anything below mid second round, the probability to be FQB is almost non existent. We have one really...
Let's keep in mind though that we do have 9 picks in this draft. With rookie UDFAs added, how many rookies will actually make the roster? For me...
I think based on performance alone, factoring scarcity at the position, he is in the range of #16th pick. The drop rate is absurd for top 8 team...
To be fair though, while he personally didn't catch as many, the team caught almost double TDs than the year before. It seems like running game...
It might be more than just 1st next year. I can see us winning 6-7 games and needing at least another 1st rounder to move up for a QB and then...
I don't think anyone said there is a fear the guy will not be good enough be a starter or a back-up. In fact I said it's fine to draft one in...
It sounds good in theory to take one every year, but in practice it does not quite work like that. The success rate of any QB drafted below...
100%. It would suck to burn #16 for this, but I guess we could recoup some value by trading him next year. And in this draft I am just not sure if...
Which is why I want to trade up for Tate, depending on the cost, but somewhere around 7-10th spot. Or if someone like Bain slides to around 10,...
He might still be there at 16. 33 probably not, but 16 is very possible. Would be interesting what Mooge will do in this scenario. Tate and Lemon...
He is going to be a top 10 pick, I don't think anyone is saying that he will suck. Just that Reese might be better.
