Peter King's Top 15 Qbs ~ ~ ~

No way at all that Romo, Leinart and Young are above Chad at this point. If he's talking total value, including future value, then they might be but if he's talking behind center next season it's definitely Chad over those 3.

 

Peter King sux! Romo ahead of Favre??????????? Favre has 16 years in the league and Romo has what 8 games.

 

Pennington over Mc Nair? No way!

 

Nice to see Manning be ranked where he should have been this whole time.

Can't believe Vince Young is even on that list.

 

Pennington belongs in the Top 10, Vince Young should be 4th. Once the guy got his feet wet, all he did was win every game.

 

Cutler/Leinart already?

McNair should be on that list.

Vick shouldn't be Top 25

 

How can you put Brees ahead of Palmer? Brees isn't better than Pennington.

 

err, check the record! Err check what they did last year! Err, check CHADWICK's record last year against teams with a winning record and then look at BREEs record- Err, no way CHADWICK is better then BREES. Maybe smarter but that doesn't translate to a beating good defenses yet. BREES does it with regularity!

 

Check Brees head to head against Chad. Check Bree's weak assed arm and nerves costing he's team a trip to the SB.

 

Poooooor argument. While Chad beat only 1, Brees only beat 2 teams with winning records this year. Neither of them would have better than 500 if they played in the AFC.

 

bulger ahead of McNabb? I don't know why I read anything that has Peter Kings name on it.

 

Peter King, is that the fat guy that occasional shows his crooked bottom row of teeth on INSIDE THE NFL


(anyone else notice his lower row of teeth are more crooked than Tom Brady)

 

That's a lot of detail to notice about both King and Tom Brady. :sad:

 

Put Pennington above Leinart, Young, Romo and Roethlisberger and he might have a decent list. Seriously who actually pays this guy

 

Nice to see Bulger get some credit actually. He's a damn good QB.

 

I would take Ben or Young over him in a heart beat. Roethlisberger was hurt all year and should not have played, it would be like comparing him to Chad 2005.

 

I believe this list is based on current talent. Not talent levels ten years ago.

 

I'd like to see Young play a little more QB and a little less RB before I say he's better than Pennington. Roethlisberger can go either way. That's a toss up IMO

 

Considering this time last year every so called "expert" had Chad on the scrap heap, we should all probably be happy they mention his name in a somewhat positive way.