http://www.fannation.com/blogs/post/14552 never gets ant respect, he at the very least has got to be ahead of delhomme, garcia is not even a starter
ehhh that isn't THAT bad of a ranking. some idiots would consider putting eli ahead of him, and some experts like salisbury would definitely put trent green ahead of him.
Once you get past #7 or #8 you could almost make an argument for any of the remaining QBs to fall anywhere on the list. Pennington certainly isn't in that top group of QBs so I'm not sure what there is to get upset about.
ben roethlisberger is 7th in this guys ranking....pleaseeeeeeeeeee....haha what a joke...ignore that whole ranking
idk, chad probably ranks anywhere from 15-20, so even though thats the last place i think you could put him without saying "wtf?", its nothing to get upset about.
chad ranks anywhere in between 10-15, not 15-20...putting Cutler and Leinart above him at this point is just plain stupid
Read the intro. He's basing it on predicted performance for the 2007 season. So there's no way to know whether these rankings are bad until we see what these players do. That being said, there's no way Alex Smith is better than Pennington in this upcoming season or any other.
everything i have read says garcia is going to be the starter in TB. and chad is a decent quarterback as long as he is in the right system but nowhere near elite level
I put something similar like this together for my page, but im not in the mood to do a write up since i have some finals to study for...so here it is 1. Colts: P. Manning 2. Patriots: Brady 3. Bengals: Palmer 4. Saints: Brees 5. Eagles: McNabb 6. Rams Bulger 7. Seahawks- Hasselbeck 8. Chargers: Rivers 9. Jets: Pennington 10. Titans: Young 11. Steelers: Rothelisberger 12. Falcons: Vick 13. Cowboys: Romo 14. Panthers: Delhomme 15. Packers: Favre 16. Giants: E. Manning 17. Broncos: Cutler 18. Chiefs: Green*/Huard 19. Jaguars: Leftwich 20. Lions: Kitna 21. Buccaneers: Garcia 22. Ravens: McNair 23. 49ers- Smith 24. Bills: Losman 25. Redskins: Campbell 26. Bears: Grossman 27. Cardinals- Leinart 28. Dolphins: Culpepper* 29. Texans: Schuab 30. Browns- Frye 31. Vikings: Jackson 32. Raiders: Walter *denotes possible trade or release
I forgot to add, these rankings are based on overall talent assessment shown by performance in NFL thus far
if you have chad ranked 9th of all qbs...you are officially an idiot...hes in the 14, 15 or 16 range leinart 27th??? mcnair 22nd?? and delhomme 14th, please...had a HORRIBLE year last year and he had steve smith and keyshawn, if you cant produce in that offense, you cant be in the top 15
Seems like a reasonable place to rank him to me. I'd put him a couple of slots higher but not too much. 1. Colts: P. Manning 2. Patriots: Brady 3. Bengals: Palmer 4. Saints: Brees 5. Eagles: McNabb 6. Rams Bulger 7. Seahawks- Hasselbeck 8. Chargers: Rivers 9. Steelers: Rothelisberger * giving him a pass on last year because of all the trauma 10. Cowboys: Romo 11. Ravens: McNair 12. Broncos: Cutler 13. Titans: Young 14. Packers: Favre 15. Chiefs: Green 16. 49ers- Smith 17. Jets: Pennington 18. Falcons: Vick 19. Panthers: Delhomme 20. Jaguars: Leftwich 21. Buccaneers: Garcia 22. Lions: Kitna 23. Giants: E. Manning 24. Cardinals- Leinart 25. Bears: Grossman 26. Bills: Losman 27. Redskins: Campbell 28. Dolphins: Culpepper* 29. Texans: Schuab 30. Browns- Frye 31. Vikings: Jackson 32. Raiders: Walter
if im so wrong, tell me besides Vince Young (in his 1 year in the NFL) who has more ability to have an impact on a team with the given talent thats ranked lower then chad? yes, chad could easily be swapped by a couple quarterbacks in the 10-15 range, but thats as far as it goes... ask yourself: if you were to rent a QB for 1 Year....which of those QB's below 15 would you really want.... and you call me an idiot
slightly updated...i made those rankings almost 3 months ago... I understand the comment about Leinart..but since hes not shown much, im reluctant to give him anything higher...a few swaps but not a world of a difference 1. Colts: P. Manning 2. Patriots: Brady 3. Bengals: Palmer 4. Saints: Brees 5. Eagles: McNabb 6. Rams Bulger 7. Seahawks- Hasselbeck 8. Chargers: Rivers 9. Titans: Young 10. Steelers: Rothelisberger 11. Jets: Pennington 12. Falcons: Vick 13. Packers: Favre 14. Cowboys: Romo 15. Giants: E. Manning 16. Panthers: Delhomme 17. Broncos: Cutler 18. Chiefs: Green*/Huard 19. Jaguars: Leftwich 20. Lions: Kitna 21. Buccaneers: Garcia 22. Ravens: McNair 23. 49ers- Smith 24. Cardinals- Leinart 25. Bills: Losman 26. Redskins: Campbell 27. Bears: Grossman 28. Dolphins: Culpepper* 29. Texans: Schuab 30. Browns- Frye 31. Vikings: Jackson 32. Raiders: Walter
Other then Leinart, Smith and Cutler being too young and Garica being too old, I don't have a problem with that list.
