Oh shut up with your racist accusations. People can compare crappy black QB's to other crappy black QB's without having idiots like you call them a racist.
I absolutely LOVE Idzik's draft thus far. I wasn't really sold on getting a QB this year, but when the top QB prospect falls in your lap at #39, you take him! Our defense is going to be nasty with the addition of Milliner and Richardson if they pan out.
Especially when you consider that he and White both played at West Virgina. The thought of "black QB" never entered my mind. .... I equate all shitty gimmick offense QB's in the same category regardless of what color they are. Would Joey Harrington be a better comparison?
At the end of round 2 he has three, legitimate, high 1st round grade picks. I didn't like milliner over Warmack or Richardson over Eifert, but the fact is we've drafted three first round grade picks so far.
Richardson, Geno, and Milliner have all fluctuated through the top 10 in mocks and Geno and Milliner in the top 5, I don't think the chances are good picking three times in the top 40 that you draft three high first round graded picks.
What kind of logic is that? What if he stinks? If he does stink then it's a HUGE waste of time and has the potential to wreck season(s). I still want us to suck this season so we can get our franchise QB in the next draft. My confidence is very low on Geno Smith and your logic for taking him is disastrous for our franchise.
7th is hardly well into the second, and just because a guy falls to the second doesn't mean he isn't a first round grade.
Yes bc in January, in the worst draft class in decades, and the worst QB class ever, a guy listed Geno in the top ten. Yes, he's the 2nd best QB of a truly bad bunch. Congrats. Throwing for 71% in the Air raid offense is par for the course. And every single guy who came from that system was completely useless in the NFL bc in the NFL you actually have to read defenses and play against speed.
I would rather keep the pick and get a top player on defense instead of two or three mediocre offensive players. At least you guys didn't spend a second round pick on a backup tight end that will be lucky to play 10 downs a year for the next 3 years.
Agreed! this is not a Pro cold weather, wind blowing QB. Not even a starting piece of shit QB. I stopped watching the draft when we picked this shit. Took forever just to talk about this F@#$King pick. OG, TE, OLD, Safety, god anything but another QB. So we sign DG just like we did Stanton last year, then get another QB. Can't cut Sanchez, can't start Smith, WTF! I grew up in NY and been a Jets fan my whole life, but the circus came to town with Rex and only gets worse. The next Jersey I buy won't be a Jets!
it is better logic than asking "what if he stinks" because "what if he is a HOF'er" easily counters that. so either your logic is just f'ing stupid, or it defeats itself.
Both played at WVU yes, but under two completely different coaches with different systems. They are totally different players, only similarities are they are black and they played at WVU.
