If a QB draft was done today, who are the top 15?

The only QB in the NFC that should be rated above Eli Manning is Drew Brees.

 

1. Tom Brady-Consistently beat every qb on this list when matters most.
2. Ben Roethlisberger
3. Peyton Manning
4. Drew Brees
5. Philip Rivers
6. Eli Manning
7. Aaron Rodgers
8. Jay Cutler
9. Joe Flacco
10. Matt Ryan
11. Romo
12. Schaub
13. Vick
14. Garrard
15. Sanchez

 

eli above rodgers is a disgrace

 

Why? Eli has had the better career.

 

How many rings does Rodgers have?

 

Same number as Rivers. Would you rate QB's 1-5 then Brady, Big Ben, Peyton, Brees, then Eli?

 

Here is my list:
1.) Brady
2.) Rodgers
3.) Ryan
4.) P.Manning
5.) Brees
6.) Rivers
7.) Roethlisberger
8.) Bradford
9.) E.Manning
10.) Vick
11.) Cassel
12.) Schaub
13.) Sanchez
14.) Flacco
15.) Freeman

Also, here is a running total I have put together for this thread:
1.) Tom Brady (278 Points)
2.) Aaron Rodgers (275 Points)
3.) Phillip Rivers (262 Points)
4.) Peyton Manning (259 Points)
5.) Matt Ryan (246.5 Points)
6.) Drew Brees (234 Points)
7.) Ben Roethlisberger (179.5 Points)
8.) Michael Vick (152.5 Points)
9.) Sam Bradford (120 Points)
10.) Joe Flacco (108.5 Points)
11.) Mark Sanchez (85 Points)
12.) Eli Manning (82.5 Points)
13.) Matt Schaub (81.5 Points)
14.) Jay Cutler (66.5 Points)
15.) Josh Freeman (63 Points)
16.) Kyle Orton (51.5 Points)
17.) Matt Stafford (39 Points)
18.) Tony Romo (24.5 Points)
19.) Matt Cassel (15.5 Points)
20.) Colt McCoy (7 Points)
21.) David Garrard (5 Points)
22.) Ryan Fitzpatrick (3 Points)
23.) Brett Favre (1 Point)

Got the totals from giving everyone's list a value of 120 points. Gave your top ranked QB 15 Points and then counted down from there.

Notes:
Mr.Electric was re #'d and Newton/Luck dropped and accounted for.
Jetfanmack had "right now" list entered throu #15.
TheCoolerGlennFoley had his three tier's averaged giving half point values.

 

Sadly if you asked this on any other teams board of just a NFL forum in general Sanchez wouldnt even crack this list. People out side of Jets fans think Sanchez is terrible.

 

Current:

1.) Brady
2.) Brees - over the last 3 years Brees has the most yards by any QB ever over a 3 year period. He also has the last Super Bowl. By all right he should be #1. The fact he is lower on most lists is a joke.
3.) Rivers
4.) Rodgers
5.) P Manning - only reason he is this low is I think he is beginning his decline. This season isn't an abberation.....going forward.
6.) Henne
7.) M. Ryan
8.) Vick
9.) Schaub
10.) Rapemyburger
11.) Eli
12.) Favre
13.) Bradford
14.) Orton
15.) Flacco
16.) Sanchez
17.) Freeman

 

Hey thanks so much for setting us delusional fans straight, you're a godsend....... kthanxbai

 

Chad Henne? WOW......

 

I think he meant to put Romo there.

 

I think he did it on purpose, as a joke.


Either that or he was in the middle of a Chad Henne fantasy as he typed his list.

 

Based on this years play, if he doesn't have more potential than Matt Ryan, I would stick my head up a cows ass..........

 

Quote honestly I forgot Romo and would have to shift my list some.....damn I always do that on top 15-20 lists.

 

1. Mark Sanchez
2. Brett Ratliff
3. Brad Smith
4. Kellen Clemens
5. Mark Brunell
6. Chad Pennington
7. Brett Favre
8. Kevin O'Connell
9. Erik Ainge
10. Vinny Testaverde
11. Quincy Carter
12. Brooks Bollinger
13. Patrick Ramsey
14. Tom Brady
15. Peyton Manning


edit: before anyone flips out, this is for POTENTIAL only.....if it was currently my list would have some changes

 

You shafted jay Fiedler and ray lucas

 

1.Philip Rivers
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Matt Ryan
4. Tom Brady
5. Ben Roethlisberger
6. Drew Brees
7. Peyton Manning
8. Michael Vick
9. Joe Flacco
10. Eli Manning
11. Mark Sanchez
12. Sam Bradford
13. Matt Schaub
14. Mathew Stafford
15. Josh Freeman

 

If these were made 2 weeks ago Sanchez and Manning would be much higher